Pumpkin varieties split into two very different jobs. Carving pumpkins are bred for size and a sturdy shell that holds its shape once cut, while eating pumpkin varieties are bred for dense, sweet flesh rather than looks.
Most farms and pick-your-own patches grow both types of pumpkins side by side, so the pale, watery giant on the doorstep and the small, tasty one on the dinner table are not the same plant at all.
Below is a rundown of the best pumpkin for eating and cooking in the UK, from Crown Prince to butternut, plus how to spot one and what to do with it in the kitchen.
Carving Pumpkins vs Eating Pumpkins: What Is the Difference?
The classic jack o’lantern is what growers call a field pumpkin, bred for size, a sturdy shell that holds its shape once carved, and a hollow cavity that scoops out easily.
None of that breeding has much to do with flavour, and the flesh is often pale, thin, watery and stringy, which is why it turns to mush in the oven rather than caramelising.
Eating pumpkin varieties are bred the other way round, for dense, dry, sweet flesh rather than size or showiness.
That is the split worth remembering across all types of pumpkins on sale in autumn: big and dramatic usually means carving, smaller and less flashy usually means dinner.
Confusingly, several of the best eating varieties are technically squash rather than pumpkin by strict botanical definition, though UK growers and shoppers use the two words loosely and interchangeably.
Popular Eating Pumpkin Varieties for UK Cooks
Most UK farms and pick-your-own patches that grow carving pumpkins also grow a few of these eating varieties alongside them. Here is what to look for and what each one is best used for:
- Crown Prince: blue grey skin, dense orange flesh and a good nutty sweetness. A top all rounder for roasting, mash and soups, and it keeps for months in a cool, dry spot.
- Butternut Squash: the eating squash you will find in every UK supermarket, and for good reason. Easy to peel, with sweet, smooth flesh for soups, risottos, curries and traybakes.
- Cinderella Pumpkin (Rouge Vif d’Etampes): a flattened, ribbed, red orange French heirloom that looks the part on a doorstep but also cooks well in soups, pies and ravioli filling.
- Munchkin: a mini pumpkin that fits in one hand, with surprisingly sweet, dense flesh. Good roasted whole and stuffed, or halved and baked as an individual portion.
- Kabocha: a Japanese squash with dark green, knobbly skin and very sweet, dry orange flesh. Excellent roasted, in curries, or mashed.
- Sugar or Pie Pumpkins: bred specifically for baking, smaller and denser than a field pumpkin with far less stringiness, the classic choice for a proper pumpkin pie.
How to Spot an Eating Variety
You do not need to be an expert to tell a cooking pumpkin from a carving one.
Eating varieties tend to be smaller than the giant field pumpkins grown for carving, and they feel heavier than their size suggests, since dense flesh weighs more than watery flesh.
Skin colour is another clue: look for the blue grey of Crown Prince, the tan of butternut, or the deep red orange of a Cinderella pumpkin, rather than the pale, uniform orange of a typical carving pumpkin.
For the full checklist, including how to judge weight, skin and stem, see our guide to how to pick the perfect pumpkin.
Cooking Your Pumpkin Once You Get It Home
Treat squash and cooking pumpkin flesh like a dense root vegetable. Peel it, cut it into even chunks, toss with a little oil and roast at a high heat until the edges catch and caramelise, which is where most of the flavour comes from.
For soups, purees and bakes, roasting first rather than boiling keeps the flesh from turning watery. A dense variety like Crown Prince, Kabocha or a small sugar pumpkin also holds its shape once cooked, which matters if you want distinct chunks rather than mush.
If you want a starting point, our pumpkin risotto recipe is a good way to use up butternut squash or Crown Prince, our pumpkin bread recipes make good use of pureed flesh from any of the sweeter varieties, and our pumpkin cheesecake recipes are exactly what a small sugar or pie pumpkin is bred for.
Why Not Pick One of Each
You do not have to choose between a good jack o’lantern and a good dinner. Most patches that grow both types will happily sell you a large field pumpkin for carving and a smaller, denser variety to take into the kitchen.
Carve the big one for the porch, taking a look at our pumpkin carving ideas first, then cook the small one for the table, and you get the full pick-your-own day out without the disappointing bowl of watery mash afterwards.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Best Pumpkin for Eating?
The best pumpkin for eating is a variety bred for dense, sweet flesh rather than size, such as Crown Prince, butternut squash or Kabocha. These hold their shape when roasted and give a far better result than a carving pumpkin in soups, pies and traybakes.
What Is the Best Pumpkin for Cooking in the UK?
For UK cooks, Crown Prince and butternut squash are the most widely available and reliable choices, found in supermarkets and at most pick-your-own farms. Small sugar pumpkins and Kabocha are also excellent if your local farm shop stocks them.
Can You Eat a Carving Pumpkin?
Yes, a carving pumpkin is edible and not harmful, but the flesh is thin, watery and stringy, so it rarely makes a good main dish. Toast the seeds, and pick an eating variety like Crown Prince instead for a proper roast or pie.
Is Butternut Squash a Pumpkin?
Botanically, pumpkins and squashes both belong to the Cucurbita genus, so the terms overlap. In everyday UK usage, pumpkin usually means the round orange carving and pie type, while squash covers pear shaped varieties like butternut. They cook in much the same way.
What Is the Best Pumpkin for Pumpkin Pie?
A small sugar or pie pumpkin is bred specifically for this and gives a dense, sweet result with minimal wateriness. Crown Prince and butternut squash also make excellent pies if you cannot find a dedicated pie pumpkin.
How Many Types of Pumpkins Are There?
Growers group pumpkins broadly into carving or field types and eating and cooking varieties such as Crown Prince and sugar pumpkins, plus ornamental minis like Munchkin and giant show pumpkins. Many of these overlap with squash, so the exact count depends on definition.
One comment